A Model for a New Emergent Approach to Building in Haiti

By Thomas Knittel, AIA, LEED® AP

The New Year always causes one to reflect on the recent past, but especially so today, the two-year anniversary of the catastrophic earthquake in Haiti. I have been fortunate to work with a dedicated group of volunteers at HOK to design a children’s center and orphanage in Port-au-Prince. Earlier this week, we presented our latest design to the client, Fondation Enfant Jesus, as well as to the U.S. Green Building Council. The results were very positive.

Our collective goal to create a nurturing and restorative place is taking shape. In many ways, though, this project is more difficult than the large, complex projects we face every day at HOK. We are striving for net zero water and waste and for the building to provide a net positive energy source – all with a design that also celebrates the amazing Haitian arts and crafts culture. Because we do not want to import materials and technologies that create a barrier to replication, we are returning to basic principles of passive design: reducing building demand as much as possible and then using limited solar and wind entrainment to make up the rest.

We have developed the design’s core principles around a balance of social, economic and environmental concerns. HOK’s design team is using biomimicry to create a locally attuned, responsive building. Biomimicry teaches us that a greater understanding of the commonalities between adaptions in a biome can serve as a guide for place-based design. Selective pressures are a biological term that describes the biotic (living) and abiotic (non-living) forces that drive change in a system. There are few places where non-living forces have wrought so much change as in Haiti.

Because 80 percent of the Haitian population lives below poverty levels, the biotic forces at play here are powerful. Over the past 100 years, forest cover has nearly vanished in Haiti, going from 60 percent to just 2 percent. The associated ecosystem services have been stripped, resulting in systemic problems caused by erosion and loss of nutrient cycling. To help restore this system, this project will leverage cyclical processes and a closed-loop resource strategy.

Biomimicry became more visible in the project after the team developed an understanding of the intended performance of the building (challenge), the strategies found in nature (solution space) and then translated the abstraction into built form.

The local builders mix concrete by hand with a bucket, and in the past have constructed structures that are not strong enough to withstand an earthquake. We are taking cues from nature to improve this process. These structures, for example, heat up in the sun. Some plant leaves create boundary layers to prevent desiccation, and certain barks have low emissivity layers that reject heat. Our goal is to establish a second building layer that keeps the concrete core cool to the touch while promoting the air movement that allows for the skin’s evaporative cooling.

Our design inspiration is found in a keystone species, the Kapok tree, which holds a powerful meaning in Haitian culture. It has practical, medicinal uses and spiritual meaning through the connection of earth to sky. The visible translation occurs in the branching support system of the building’s balcony system as well as in the low emissivity, heat shedding characteristics of its second skin. Leonardo da Vinci observed the branching system of trees, where the mother limb is twice the area of the daughter limb branched pair. This simple empirical formula guides the design of the diagrid facing the courtyard.

The Kapok is an adapted and emergent tree, meaning that in many areas of the world it rises above the rainforest canopy. Extending the visible and literal tree-like diagrid to the metaphor of the entire building is an important aspect of a passive building that needs tending, as the children will become participants in the life of the building. The below-grade area will serve as the building’s “roots,” cleaning and storing water and recycling nutrients from waste into biogas for cooking. The first three stories will function as the structure’s “trunk.” Protecting the building like tree bark, a “boundary layer” will shield exterior walkways and vertical surfaces from direct sunlight while allowing for daylighting and natural ventilation. Rooftop gardens will serve as the “foliage,” supporting the solar energy system and providing additional green space.

This large idea is supported by many small elements related to how the people will use this building every day. Mopping floors in the shaded and ventilated surfaces, for example, provides perceived cooling and surface temperature reduction experienced through bare feet. Vertical green walls flanking the main stair have perches for endemic epiphytes (air plants), and we are suggesting that each adopting parent bring a plant to add to the wall. The rooftop garden includes beds for urban farming.

The new children’s center is taller than most of the buildings around it, and we hope it will be a model for a new ‘emergent’ approach to building in Haiti.

Read past posts about Project Haiti.

Support Project Haiti.

YouTube Preview Image

As a vice president in HOK’s Seattle studio, Thomas Knittel, AIA, LEED AP, is passionately committed to sustainable architecture. He holds a Master in Design Studies from the Harvard Graduate School of Design.

3 Comments
  1. January 15th, 2012 - 11:16 am
    chip crawford said:

    Thom…Mary Ann…Paul…and the entire Haiti team…what an inspiring effort…Congratulations on such meaningful and purposeful inspiration! I am so proud of the courage you show in taking something like this on. The solution looks elegant and completely smart.

    I also applaud the root purpose. Your fully integrated thinking is as beautiful in its ‘simple complexity’ as the community of adoption itself…which by the way…is all about being truely FIT in the most important way…in caring for and nurturing your young…

    As a member of the adoption community…I want to personally thank you all for this amazing gift.

  2. February 1st, 2012 - 9:06 pm
    Ralph Raymond said:

    Thank you for the beautiful narrative which helps convey an amazing design embedded with such cultural richness. The key features of this design are the answers to that which plagues the country. I thank you as both a Haitian and a student of architecture.

  3. June 26th, 2012 - 7:30 pm

    Amazing project. Question: Is anyone using confined masonry techniques in Haiti? Confined masonry has been shown to be cost effective and safe in high seismic zones. Also, projects like this can benefit from employing insulated thermal mass, where the building interior will remain “cool to the touch”, as mentioned in the above post. Also, does HOK have a confined masonry expert who could answer a few questions ? Thanks! Marty

Comments Post a Comment

HOK encourages comments to be short and to the point; as a general rule, they should not run longer than the original post. Comments should show a courteous regard for the presence of other voices in the discussion. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments that do not adhere to this standard.